COVID Vaccine Fact Sheet
History of Vaccines Vaccinations have historically been compulsory, where it was a legal requirement under the Vaccinations Act 1853 for children to be vacc...
History of Vaccines Vaccinations have historically been compulsory, where it was a legal requirement under the Vaccinations Act 1853 for children to be vacc...
Uber Loses Supreme Court Hearing Uber’s work status battle within the Gig Economy has been ongoing since 2016 when two employees took Uber to an Employment Tri...
Are you looking for a reason to get out and enjoy the improving weather, or escape the working from home life and recharge your batteries? Well look no further...
PIB Insurance Brokers (PIB) has partnered with the Police Digital Security Centre (PDSC) as part of their campaign to promote cyber security across their clien...
How far have you walked since the beginning of February? Exercise is so good for our mental and physical health. For some, like our CEO Justine, walking has ta...
SAVE YOUR BUSINESS MONEY, CUT BUSINESS ENERGY COSTS TODAY !!An easy way to cut your outgoings is to start with the basics. Energy is an essential for most busin...
The Gig Economy has received profound attention in the media for a number of years.
The high-profile debate over worker v self-employed status was triggered in part by a test case brought by Mr Aslam, an Uber driver, who claimed that he and many others should be paid the National Minimum Wage and should also receive paid leave, in accordance with the Working Time Regulations 1998.
In 2016, when the initial claim was brought, there were approximately 40,000 Uber drivers, of whom at least 30,000 were positioned in London, with over two million passengers registered to use its services at the time.
Uber vehemently denied throughout the proceedings that its drivers were classed as “workers” on the basis that the drivers were independent and self-employed. Uber argued that contracts were made between the driver and the passenger and that the drivers were at liberty to choose whether or not to accept an assignment, each time a journey was requested by a user.
However, the Tribunal found in favour of the Claimant’s and labelled Uber drivers as “workers” taking the Gig Economy by storm.
Both the Employment Appeal Tribunal and the Court of Appeal upheld the Tribunal’s decision. Earlier reports on the EAT decision can be found here: http://insights.brabners.com/post/102ek6h/ubers-appeal-against-the-worker-status-decision-has-failed-but-will-the-saga.
However, on 19 February 2021, the last word was handed down by the Supreme Court, following a two-day hearing, which took place in July 2020.
The Decision – The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed Uber’s appeal
The Supreme Court outlined that the primary purpose of key employment legislation is to protect vulnerable individuals with little or no say on their working conditions. Control has always been a key factor in determining whether an individual will be considered self-employed or a worker and employers are prohibiting from contracting out of Employment Protection.
In summary, the Supreme Court’s decision was attributed to five specific factors that confirmed the Tribunal’s decision was correct and that Uber drivers are indeed “workers”:
Taking the above five factors together, the Supreme Court found that the transportation service is very tightly defined and controlled by Uber and as such, the driver would be deemed a worker.
In practice, the only way that the driver can increase their earning is by working longer hours and meeting performance targets set by Uber, as opposed to being entrepreneurs in their own right.
In respect of working time, the Supreme Court also confirmed that the drivers working time was not just during accepted assignments, but for any time spent logged into the app where they were ready and willing to work.
What does this mean for employers?
The key point for establishing the true relationship between a Company and an individual is the level of control that the Company has over the Individuals ability to earn a living and in doing so, how their services are delivered to the end user.
This is not new to the employment world and is a long-established principle that many employers have tried to circle around, by setting out loose intentions to control the relationship via service contracts/consultancy agreements, however, in practice they maintain tightly defined control over the individuals.
Where significant control is retained or performed in practice, it is highly likely that the individual will acquire worker status and as such, have a right to receive the minimum wage, as well as 5.6 weeks’ paid annual leave each year.
This is in addition to other rights that workers also enjoy but does not extend as far as the rights that an “employee” will enjoy i.e. the right to redundancy pay and not to be unfairly dismissed.
Clarifying the status of an individual’s engagement to carry out work is more important than ever, due to the increasing number of people engaged in the gig economy or who work outside of a traditional employment relationship who may not always get the benefits that they are entitled to as a result of this Judgment, but also with the changes to IR35 due to take effect from April 2021.
For more information on the topic, please contact Trishna Modessa-Parekh or another member of our Employment team.
We are delighted to be hosting Colours Fashion show for a third year at Plungington Community Centre.Come and grab yourself a Christmas bargain or treat yoursel...
The Chancellor of the Exchequer will present the next Budget to Parliament on Wednesday 30th October 2024. Following the Speech, we are hosting a FREE seminar w...
Following on from the success of Your Business Bootcamp, Community & Business Partners are pleased to run its online versionYour Business Bootcamp Bitesize will...
Whether you are in the early stages and just seeking information or you have been considering adoption for a while, joining us at one of our online information...
The Konsortia Partnership are groups of local, professional small and medium-sized (SME’s) businesses in property and construction based in Manchester and Prest...
OverviewThis webinar aims to provide participants with a comprehensive understanding of the public sector buying process, with a specific focus on governance pr...